1946-1968
(23 linear feet)

Accession 1901


© Hagley Museum and Library  
P.O. Box 3630   Wilmington, DE 19807-0630  

Logo of the Hagley Museum and Library
Table of contents
Abstract
The Technitrol law suit, 1967-1968, revolved around the question of who developed the magnetic storage drum. These records, which were acquired from Seymour Yutter, the lawyer for Technitrol, include trial transcripts, briefs, depositions and discovery documents which describe the development of magnetic storage technology in the late 1940s and early 1950s.

Background note:
Technitrol, Inc. was incorporated on April 15, 1947, by John F. Koch, Jr., E. Stuart Eichert, Jr., Gordon Palmer, Jr., and T. K. Sharpless, as Technitrol Engineering Company. The corporation opened its doors to business on May 1st of the same year. The four founders provided the paid-in capital of $1,000. Their goal was to develop the new technology of high speed computation for military and industrial purposes. Prior to their full time work at Technitrol, Eichert, Koch, and Sharpless had been employed at the Moore School of Electrical Engineering, while Palmer had been Assistant Director of Research at International Register Company in Philadelphia.

Technitrol's first contract was to develop a small, low-cost radar to be used in tug boats and larger pleasure craft. However, because of new Federal Communications Commission regulations and increased costs, the project was never completed. In the summer of 1947, Sharpless and Koch became aware of the problems that commercial airlines was facing in making and recording reservations for passenger flights. On August 4, 1947 Koch and Sharpless met with representatives of American Airlines to discuss a computerized reservation system. Although American's representatives said that the airline would not pay Technitrol for development of the system, Sharpless recommended that Technitrol proceed at its own expense to develop a reservation system. A patent for Technitrol's “Reservisor” system was ultimately filed on May 26, 1948. In June of 1948 the “Reservisor” system developed at Technitrol was demonstrated to the representatives of American Airlines, however the airline declined to purchase the system.

On September 23, 1952, Technitrol recorded a patent for the Magnetic Data Storage System that it used in its development of the “Reservisor” system. The primary objective of this Magnetic Data Storage System was to provide a means by which remote terminals, i.e., an airline reservation desk, could quickly determine the availability (or non-availability) of seat reservations on a particular flight. To complete this reservation relevant data as to the number and flight were communicated to a centrally located storage unit. The appropriate storage register, either a length of magnetic tape or a sector of a magnetic disk, was selected, and the number of additional reservations desired was added to the previous total. Provided this new total did not exceed the number of available reservations, the total was stored back in the appropriate register for similar access in the future.

Two problems arose during the development stage of this system. The first involved a process of register selection, that is, a way to address a particular register so that the previously stored material could be easily accessed when desired. The other problem occurred when the system was interrupted, by a power failure. Since the counter, an electronic device, lost count when the power was cut off, it was necessary to provide an automatic reset feature in order to synchronize the counter and the clock disk. This system of addressing a register and providing a reset feature was the foundation of the Sharpless-Eichert patent.

However, during the 1940s, Engineering Research Associates (ERA) a St. Paul, Minnesota based firm, which was doing top secret research as part of the U.S. Navy's cryptographic program, had developed a similar system. Thus when Technitrol tried to license its invention, a bitter patent infringement suit resulted. In February 1986, the former patent attorney for Technitrol, donated the records generated by this litigation to the Hagley Museum and Library.

Scope and content
The records which surfaced during the Technitrol Suit provide a fascinating picture of the early history of the computer industry. Series I-III consists of documents that were collected by the Technitrol lawyers through the discovery process.

Series I documents the work done at the Harvard Computational Laboratory between 1948 and 1955. It contains two boxes of progress reports that trace the “Investigation for Design of Digital Calculating Machinery.” This project resulted in the production of Harvard's Mark IV computer.

Series II documents the history of Engineering Research Associates, a Minneapolis computer company that was working under contract for the United States Navy during the late 1940s and early 1950s. The documentation on ERA, which has always been shrouded in secrecy because of the company's involvement in the Navy's cryptographic program, is extremely interesting. These internal company memoranda and progress reports show that as early as 1943 the Navy had recognized that the computer with its ability to rapidly manipulate data streams was a natural tool for encoding and decoding messages. During the second World War the Navy sponsored research in this secret work. Its most successful unit was led by Commander Howard T. Engstrom, in peacetime a professor of mathematics at Yale and Lt. Commander William C. Norris, who had been a sales engineer for Westinghouse. In 1945 Norris and Engstrom went into business for themselves and with the encouragement of Navy Secretary James Forrestal, established Engineering Research Associates. They negotiated a cost-plus contract with the government and began recruiting engineers, physicists, and mathematicians to work on top secret computer projects. By 1946, ERA now based in St. Paul, Minnesota, had established itself as one of the most advanced computer companies in the world with a reputation for engineering genius. The records show that it was the first company to develop a stored program digital computer, The Atlas, which was completed in the fall of 1950. This machine contained 2700 vacuum tubes and 2385 crystal diodes. It ran 24 hours a day with only ten percent of the time being allotted for maintenance. However, ERA's connection with the government was soon to be broken by an expose in Drew Pearson's “Washington Merry-Go-Round”, Pearson charged that the founding of ERA and the awarding of its initial contracts represented a conflict of interest for Engstrom and Norris as these former Naval technical specialists had clearly taken advantage of their war-time government connections in order to set up a company for their own profit. By 1952, ERA's connection with the Navy had been broken as the company, under considerable economic and political pressure, merged with Sperry-Rand. However, five years later William Norris led his engineers back to Minnesota where they established the Control Data Corporation.

Series II of the Technitrol Suit Records traces the stormy history of Engineering Research Associates. This series contains laboratory notebooks; internal company memoranda, monthly and weekly progress reports on the Atlas computer project. This material is arranged by exhibit number which are listed in the order that they were submitted to the court.

Series III contains other background records that were assembled during the discovery proceedings. This series includes data on the Gun Direction Computer (1961) and the Minuteman D 17 Computer (1960-1970). Also included are records tracing the development of the ENIAC and EDVAC computer at the University of Pennsylvanis's Moore School of Electrical Engineering.

Series IV are the Prior Art Files which contain documentation on John Atanasoff's ABC Computer, the Harvard Mark IV and the Eckert-Mauchly ENIAC and UNIVAC.

Series V is the court record which include trial transcripts - briefs, appeals, affidavits, depositions and related documents.


Administrative information

Restrictions
Copyright restrictions may apply.

Provenance
Gift of Seymour Yutter

Processing information
July 8, 1987

Processed by Michael H. Nash


Added entries

Subjects
  • ABC (Computer).
  • Aiken, Howard H. (Howard Hathaway), 1900-1973.
  • Airlines--Reservation systems.
  • American Airlines, inc.
  • Atanasoff, John V. (John Vincent).
  • ATLAS (Computer).
  • Brown, Lowell.
  • Cohen, Arnold A.
  • Computer engineering.
  • Computer industry--United States.
  • Computers.
  • Control Data Corporation.
  • Coombs, John.
  • Cryptography.
  • Curtiss, John Hamilton, 1909-1977.
  • Eckert-Mauchly Computer Corporation (Philadelphia, Pa.).
  • EDVAC (Computer).
  • Eichert, E. Stuart (Edwin Stuart), 1920-1976.
  • Electronic data processing.
  • Electronic digital computers.
  • Engineering Research Associates.
  • Engstrom, Howard T. (Howard Theodore), 1902-1962.
  • ENIAC (Computer).
  • Forrestal, James, 1892-1949.
  • Gun direction computer.
  • Harvard University. Computation Laboratory.
  • Institute for Advanced Study (Princeton, N.J.).
  • Keye, William R., 1921-.
  • Magnetic cores.
  • Magnetic memory (Calculating-machines).
  • Mark IV (Calculator).
  • Massachusetts Institute of Technology.
  • Mauchly, John W. (John William), 1907-1980.
  • Minuteman (Computer).
  • Moore School of Electrical Engineering.
  • Norris, William C., 1911-.
  • Northwest Airlines, inc.
  • Project Goldberg.
  • Project Whirlwind.
  • Raytheon Manufacturing Company.
  • Rees, Mina Spiegel, 1902-.
  • Rockwell International.
  • Sperry Rand Corporation.
  • Technitrol, Inc.
  • United States. National Bureau of Standards.
  • United States. Office of Naval Research.
  • Univac computer.
  • Whirlwind computer.
Contact information

Hagley Museum and Library
[http://www.hagley.org/library]
P.O. Box 3630
Wilmington, DE 19807-0630

©July 8, 1987

 


Inventory

Series I: Documents Collected Through Discovery at Harvard University


Harvard Computational Laboratory - Investigation for Design of Digital Calculating Machinery - Progress Reports 1, 3-16
May 10, 1948-February 10, 1950
Box 1

Harvard Computational Laboratory - Investigation for Design of Digital Calculating Machinery - Progress Reports 17, 19-33
February 10, 1951-May, 1954
Box 2

1. Harvard Computation Laboratory - Investigation For Design of Digital Calculating Machinery - Progress Reports 34-36, 38, 41
May 20, 1954-August, 1955
Box 3

2. Annals of the Computation Laboratory of Harvard University (Volumes 14 and 15) includes “Tables of the Error Function and Its First Twenty Derivatives
1951-1952

3. Engineering Research Institute (University of Michigan) “Shoran Distance Computations with Tables Based on Clarke 1866” prepared by Harry C. Carver, Professor Mathematics for Air Research and Development Command
June 1953
(3 vol.)

Series II: Documents Collected Through Discovery - Engineering Research Associates


1. ERA Chronology
Box 4

2. ERA Invention Dated Picture

3. Twenty Four Digit Parallel Computer with Magnetic Drum Memory Report submitted by Engineering Research Associates to the National Bureau of Standards
1949

4. Thirty Digit Magnetic Storage Drum Parallel Computers Report submitted by Engineering Research Associates to the National Bureau of Standards
1949

5. J. M. Coombs, “Storage of Numbers on Magnetic Tape”, Engineering Research Associates, Inc., Engineering and Research: The Key To The Future
n.d.

F. C. Mullaney, Design Features of the ERA 1101 Computer

EXHIBIT FILES

EXHIBIT NO. B 1-1.  6. Technitrol Company Engineering Drawings and Financial Records
1947-1948

C 243.  7. Engineering Research Associates, Inc. Task Order I, Progress Reports, No. 5
May-June 1947

C 244.  8. ERA Progress Report No. 6
July-August 1947

E 1.  9. Arnold Cohen Laboratory Notebook
1946-1948

E 2.  10. William R. Key Laboratory Notebook
1947

E 3.  11. ERA, “Selective Alteration of a Digital Data In A Magnetic Drum Computer Memory”
December 1947

E 5.  12. ERA (S.M. Rubens) “Magnetic Recording of Pulses For The Storage of Digital Information”,
June 19, 1947

E 6.  13. ERA (Arnold Cohen) “Internal Storage by Magnetic Recording”
1947

E 7.  14. ERA (John Coombs) “Storage of Numbers on Magnetic Tape”

E 9.  15. ERA, G. A. Hardenberg Laboratory Notebook
1947

E 10.  ERA, James G. Miles Laboratory Notebook
1948

E 11.  16. ERA, S. M. Rubens, Laboratory Notebook
1946-1947

E 12.  17. ERA, Robert J. Eulberg, Laboratory Notebook
1947

E 13.  ERA, Donald R. Dubbert, Laboratory Notebook
1947

E 14.  ERA, D. W. Ammerman, Laboratory Notebook
1946-1947

E 15-32.  1. ERA Task 13 Atlas Progress Reports 1-17
1947-1949
Box 5

E 33-42.  2. ERA Task 13 Atlas Progress Reports 19-38
1949

E 43.  3. ERA Atlas Report, Vol. 1

E 44.  4. ERA Atlas Reports, Vol. 2

E 45.  5. ERA Task 1 Progress Reports (5, 6 & 8)
1947

E 46.  6. ERA Task 13 Progress Reports, Nos. 29-51

E 47.  7. Project Goldberg Progress Reports, Nos. 3-13

E 48.  8. ERA Bimonthly Progress Report Task Order I
November 1946-January 1947

ERA Laboratory Notebook William Keye
1948

E 49-1.  ERA Memorandum re Symposium on Magnetic Drum Applications (J. H. Howard to R. I. Meader)
March 5, 1948

E 49-A1.  ERA Bimonthly Progress Report Task Order I
January-March 1947

E 50.  Excerpts from EDVAC Progress Report, Vol. 2
1946

E 51-52.  9. ERA Goldberg Project Progress and Summary Reports
1946-1947

E 53.  10. Arnold Cohen's Laboratory Notebook
1947-1950

E 54.  John M. Coombs' Laboratory Notebook
1946

E 62.  11. ERA Arnold Cohen Notebook Project B3001 Project Whirlwind B3001
1948

E 63.  ERA Correspondence and Memoranda
1946-1952

E 63 942.  12. ERA Magnetic Storage System

E 64.  13. ERA Arnold Cohen's Laboratory Notebook
1949-1955

E 65.  14. ERA Atlas Progress Reports, 29-43
1950-1951

E 66.  15. ERA Goldberg Project Task 9 Progress Reports, 29-60
1948-1952

E 67.  16. ERA Goldberg Project Progress Reports, 3-13
1946-1947

E 68.  17. ERA Goldberg Project Progress Reports, 1-14
1947-1948

E 69.  18. ERA Task Order #50 Bureau of Ships, August Report
1947

E 70.  19. ERA Progress Reports and Memoranda re Atlas Project
1947-1950

E 71.  1. ERA, Goldberg Project Weekly Progress Reports
July 21, 1946-February 2, 1947
Box 6

E 72.  ERA, Correspondence re Atlas Project
1947

E 73.  ERA, Atlas Project Interim Reports
1950

E 74.  ERA, Goldberg Project Weekly Project Reports
August-December, 1946

E 75.  2. ERA, Goldberg Project, Patent Disclosures and Correspondence
1946-1947

E 76.  3. ERA, Goldberg Project Progress Reports and Correspondence
1946

E 77.  ERA, Goldberg Project Progress Reports
January-February 1947

E 78.  ERA, Goldberg Project Progress Reports
1946

E 79-81.  ERA Patent Disclosure in Magnetic Drum Computers
1947

E 83.  5. ERA, Frick and Thomas Laboratory Notebooks
1947

E 84.  ERA, Arnold Cohen Laboratory Notebook
1947

E 85.  6. ERA, Lowell Brown Laboratory Notebook
1947-1948

E 86-111.  See Oversize Box, Page 8

F 1-5.  7. ERA Correspondence primarily with the Office of Naval Research re the 1946 Government Contract
1946-1948

F 12.  8. ERA Correspondence with the Office of Naval Research re Government Contracts
1946-1947

F 13.  ERA Correspondence & Reports re Project B-3001 Whirlwind
1946

F 14.  Project B-3001 Informal Project Notes
1948

F 18.  ERA memo: Tentative Specifications for a Computing Device for Most Rapid Feasible Delivery
1948

F 21.  ERA Correspondence re Project B-3001
1947

F 22.  ERA Correspondence re Atlas Project
1947-1951

F 24.  ERA Correspondence
1948-1950

F 25.  9. James Miles Notebook re Airline Reservation System
1948

G 1.  10. ERA Proposal For Airlines Reservation System for TWA
1946

G 4.  ERA Proposal for Automatic Space Reservation System for Northwest Airlines
1947

G 5.  ERA Proposal for Automatic Space Reservation System for Airline Operation
1947

G 6.  ERA Proposal - Sales Demonstrator - Magnetic Storage Techniques (Temporary Storage of Telegraphic Intelligence)
1948

G 14.  11. Airline Reservation Systems - R. M. Kalb's Personal File
1947

G 16.  William Norris Correspondence
1947

G 18.  Airline Reservation System for Northwest Airlines (memoranda)
1947-1952

G 20.  ERA Progress Report - Airline Reservation System
1948

J.  12. Atlas Instruction Manual Vol. 1
1953

O.  1. Eckert-Mauchly Computer Corporation - Engineering Reports on the BINAC
1949
Box 7

Q.  2. Princeton University Institute for Advanced Study,

3. “Interim Progress Report on the Physical Realization of an Electronic Computing Instrument”
January 1, 1947-1949

Z.  4. William Field Laboratory Notebook
1947

Documents collected through discovery - Princeton University Institute for Advanced Study and Collatoral Material

C 322.  Princeton - Institute for Advanced Study Progress Report, Realization of an Electronic Computing Instrument by J. H. Bigelow

5. J. M. Pomorene, R. J. Slutz, W. H. Ware
January 1, 1947

Preliminary discussion of the Logical Design of an Electronic Computing Instrument, by Arthur W. Burks, Herman Goldstine and John von Newmann
1946

D 664-668.  Meeting of Cohen, Coombs, Keyes, re B-3001 Programs and collateral memoranda
September 8, 1947

D 675.  ERA Proposal Submitted to the Office of Naval Research “Selective Alteration of Digital Data in a Magnetic Storage Drum
December 1, 1947

Series III: Documents Collected Through Discovery - U. S. Government


Gun Direction Computer (XM-18)
1961
Box 8

Minuteman D-17 Computer
1960-1970

Documents Collected Through Discovery of Moore School of Electrical Engineering Records
Box 9-10


“Theory and Techniques for Design of Electronic Digital Computers” John Mauchly Lectures

EDVAC Progress Reports

Documents Collected Through Discovery
Box 11

Raytheon Manufacturing Company

“The Preliminary Design of an Automatic Digital Computing System” developed under contract with the National Bureau of Standards for the Office of Naval Research
August 12, 1947

Series IV: Prior Art Files


Prior Art Files - Records re John Atanasoff's ABC computer and the Harvard Mark IV
Box 12

Patents assigned by Sharpless to Technitrol Corp. as well as those assigned to the Eckert-Mauchly Computer Corporation.
Box 13

Prior Art Files Working Trial Brief and Summary of Discovery Procedure
Box 14

Defense Marketing Measurers - “Data Collection Processing and Retrieval System Designed to Construct Statistical Measurements of the U. S. Defense Industry” (Computer printout) Variables measured include dollar volume, market share, and product mix of the markets and companies for the aerospace companies. The data in these printouts is arranged by hardware category, phase, and system category.
1960-1968
Box 15

Series V: Court Records


Technitrol vs. Control Data Miscellaneous Trial
Box 16

Documents including working trial brief, appeal; patent material and related correspondence.
Box 17

Technitrol vs. Sperry-Rand material includes Arnold Cohen's deposition (February 6-10, 1961), Kite Sharpless patent (records ENIAC, EDVAC), summary of Kite Sharpless' deposition (December 2, 1958), extracts from progress reports and notes and photocopies re history of ERA.
Box 18

Technitrol vs. USA - Stenographic Trial Transcript Prior Art Files
May 24, 1967-January 16, 1968
Box 19

Technitrol vs. USA
Box 20

1. ERA Patent Magnetic Storage Drum (Coombs),
1948

2. Affidavits Kite Sharpless

3. Exhibits - re Technitrol Engineering Company's effort to build a computerized reservation system for American Airlines (2 black binders)

4. Technitrol Chronology and Invention Dates

5. Legal Correspondence and Papers - Patent and Interference Files
1951-1960

1. Technitrol vs. USA (continued) Legal Correspondence - Patent and Interference Files
Box 21

2. Technitrol vs. Trustees of University of Pennsylvania depositions of Dr. Carl Chambers, Dr. Donald Murray and Dr. Irven Travis
1967

Duplicate Exhibit Files (ERA)
Box 22

E 86.  L. D. Findley Notebook
1947-1949
O.S. 1

E 87.  J. T. Brands Notebook
1947-1950

E 88.  Arnold Cohen Notebook
1947-1949

E 89.  D. W. Ammerman & A. P. Hendrickson Notebook
1947-1949

E 90.  G. A. Hardenbergh Notebook
1947-1949

E 91.  J. C. Miles Notebook
1947
O.S. 2

E 92.  B. M. Sifford
1948

E 93.  D. D. Christensen Notebook
1947-1949

E 94.  L. D. Findley Notebook
1947-1950

E 95.  A. F. Vitalli Notebook
1947-1948

E 96.  G. W. Lund Notebook
1948-1949

E 97.  W. L. Anderson Notebook
1949

E 98.  H. H. Kurth Notebook
1949

E 99.  D. D. Christensen Notebook
1949
O.S. 3

E 100.  D. H. Raudenbush Notebook
1949

E 101.  W. H. Armoth Notebook
1950

E 102.  D. T. Greenwood Notebook
1948

E 103.  J. M. Coombs & W. P. Burrell Notebook
1947-1950

E 104.  A. P. Hendrickson Notebook
1948-1949

E 105.  E. M. Anderson Notebook
1948

E 106.  F. S. Kline & W. S. Field Notebook
1948-1949

E 107.  J. G. Miles Notebook
1948

E 108.  J. Kelar Notebook
1948-1950
O.S. 4

E 109.  E. D. Korhone Notebook
1948-1950

E 110.  L. W. Reid Notebook
1948-1949

E 111.  F. C. Mullaney Notebook
1948-1950